Moral Assessment

+

Abhorrent

+ +

Disturbing

+ + +

Acceptable

+ + + +

Wholesome

+ + + + +

Exemplary

Technical Assessment

Poor

• •

Below average

• • •

Average

• • • •

Above average

• • • • •

Excellent

CINEMA Rating Guide

VA

For viewers of all ages

V13

For viewers age 13 and below with parental guidance

V14

For viewers 14 and above

V18

For mature viewers 18 and above

NP

Not for public viewing

 

Title:

MAID IN MANHATTAN

Running Time: 

105 min

Lead Cast:

Jennifer Lopez, Ralph Fiennes, Natasha Richardson, Stanley Tucci, Tyler Posey, Frances Conroy, Chris Eigeman, Amy Sedaris, Marissa Matrone, Priscilla Lopez

Director: 

Wayne Wang

Producers:

Paul Schift, Deborah Schindler

Screenwriters:

John Hughes, Kevin Wade

Music:

Alan Silvestre

Editor: 

Eric Searn

Genre:

Comedy/Romance

Cinematography: 

Karl Walter Lindelaub

Distributor:

Columbia Pictures

Location: 

Manhattan

Technical Assessment: 

• • •

Moral Assessment: 

+ + +

CINEMA Rating:  

For viewers 13 and below with parental guidance

 

Maid at a posh hotel Marissa (Jennifer Lopez) is persuaded by her best friend and co-worker to try on an elegant and expensive suit they find in the suite they are cleaning.  She is then persuaded to go for a walk in it.  She and her young son meet assemblyman running for a senate seat Chris (Ralph Fiennes) who is attracted to her at first sight, thinking she is a hotel guest. She keeps her identity and tries to avoid him on succeeding occasions.  However, his pursuit and her growing interest in him win and she accepts an invitation to attend an important function as his partner.  Where will this blooming romance go? Can she tell him that she works as an all-around maid, when the time comes?  Could a single mother with a young son and in a lowly position be suitable for a man of his stature?

This is an old story made new by time and the circumstances. The storyline is thin; necessary details about the main characters are not revealed like, where is Marissa coming from, why is she a solo parent, where does she get the beautiful gowns and jewelry she wears to the affair?   The movie length is made up of episodes showing their growing feelings for each other and how they are dealing with it.  The exposition of the various scenes – production design, lighting, composition, directing, etc. – is suitably entertaining for this light romantic story.  As a first-timer in a comedy, Ralph Fiennes does fine. Jennifer Lopez – as Marissa, the focus of the film – is more than adequate for her role.

It starts with a deception that is carried through two thirds of the film. This, however, is not taken as of great consequence. When revealed, it is eventually forgiven.  Maid in Manhattan attempts to project some serious messages and values.  In visuals and in dialogue the following are emphasized: fairness and compassion for the workers, woman empowerment, to rise above the ranks, "the only difference" between the simple employees and the elite is "money" which should not be an essential difference. This last is said by Marissa's personnel head who resigns when she is fired. He also said "It is true that in our work we serve people with much money, but that does not make us their servants."

 

(Date Reviewed:  March 7, 2003)

 

HOMEABOUT USNEWSPROGRAMSDOCUMENTSMOVIE REVIEWSARCHIVES
RATINGSCALENDARPHOTO GALLERYCONTACT USPRIVACY POLICY | LINKS