Moral Assessment

+

Abhorrent

+ +

Disturbing

+ + +

Acceptable

+ + + +

Wholesome

+ + + + +

Exemplary

Technical Assessment

Poor

• •

Below average

• • •

Average

• • • •

Above average

• • • • •

Excellent

CINEMA Rating Guide

VA

For viewers of all ages

V13

For viewers age 13 and below with parental guidance

V14

For viewers 14 and above

V18

For mature viewers 18 and above

NP

Not for public viewing

 

Title:

MASTER AND COMMANDER

Running Time: 

139 min.

Lead Cast:

Russel Crowe, Paul Bettany, Max Pirkis, Billy Boyd, James D'Arcy, Mark Jewis Jones, Chris Larkin, Richard McCabe, Lee Ingleby, David Threfall

Director: 

Peter Weir

Producers:

Samuel Goldwyn Jr., Duncan Henderson, John Bard Manulis, Peter Weir

Screenwriters:

Peter Weir & John Collee

Music:

Iva Davies, Christopher Gordon

Editor: 

Lee Smith

Genre:

Adventure/Action/ War

Cinematography: 

Russel Boyd

Distributor:

20th Century Fox

Location: 

Ocean near Brazil

Technical Assessment: 

• • • ½

Moral Assessment: 

+ + +

CINEMA Rating:  

For viewers 14 and above

 

It is 1805 in the era of Napoleon's expansionism.  The intense rivalry between the French and the English is reflected in the orders of the British navy to Capt. Jack Aubrey (Russel Crowe) of the M/S Surprise to keep the French off the waters of Brazil by destroying or capturing the French warship Acheron.  Though a man-of-war, the British M/S Surprise is no match for its formidable quarry in size, speed, guns and manpower.  Moreover, the ship's surgeon Dr. Stephen Maturin ( Paul Bettany) is a dyed-in-the-wool biologist who wishes to gather undiscovered specimens of beetles, bees and other wild life for which reason Aubrey has to visit rarely explored areas of the world, like the Galapagos Islands.  The harrowing storms around Cape Horn and the simmering animosities among the crew are aggravating disadvantages but on the first sea encounter with the Acheron, the M/S Surprise survives due to the quick thinking of Capt. Aubrey.  The captain now realizes that to win, he must use strategy rather than gunfire.

In this age of heavily computerized action sequences and fantastic special effects of air-borne Kung-Fu fighters, this down-to-earth, well crafted movie is a welcome change.  Based on Patrick O'Brian's novel entitled The Far Side of the World, this sea adventure may seem old-fashioned, but it exudes as much vitality and exuberance as any mainly digitally enhanced movie.  The viewer enjoys not only the exciting battles of the sea but also the stimulating duels of minds of two diametrically opposed personalities superbly given life by its lead actors: Russel Crowe as Capt. Aubrey, the realist, the man of action, the brilliant strategist, cool in the midst of battle, decisive, unbending in pursuit of a goal but fair to everyone, a leader of men; and Paul Bettany as Dr. Maturin, the captain's friendly but argumentative devil's advocate, philosophical, reflective, just as "graceful" under stress.   Many of the scenes are very dark but these are offset by the beautiful cinematography of pristine nature in peaceful sunlight.  The close attention to details, the well-done script and very good direction of Peter Weir all deserve mention.  The violin cello duets of classical music played by the main leads are a nice touch. They not only ease the tension at times but also round out the characters of Aubrey and Maturin.

Courage, devotion to duty, loyalty to country, respect for authority and fairness in leadership are clearly depicted in this picture.  This is the story of men who find themselves in the most trying circumstances but who risk life and limb to achieve a worthy goal.  Capt. Aubrey best exemplifies these qualities—he has faith in the resources of the mind and continues to hope in adverse conditions and to affirm life.  Leaders may learn something from him.  In one instance when a crew member commits an infraction, he has to balance the need to discipline and the need to be fair. He cannot compromise.  He has to make a decision, no matter how difficult, as a true leader of men should.  There are prolonged and ferocious fighting scenes, as might be expected in stories of that age and genre, but on the whole these are balanced by elements that reveal soul, such as the dying French captain's gesture of bequeathing his sword to the captain of the victorious enemy ship, and the men's solemn recitation of the The Lord's Prayer as the bodies of their comrades are lowered at sea. This is one movie that beautifully weds bravery with tears, violence with violins.

 

(Date Reviewed: November 21, 2003)

 

HOMEABOUT USNEWSPROGRAMSDOCUMENTSMOVIE REVIEWSARCHIVES
RATINGSCALENDARPHOTO GALLERYCONTACT USPRIVACY POLICY | LINKS