Moral Assessment

+

Abhorrent

+ +

Disturbing

+ + +

Acceptable

+ + + +

Wholesome

+ + + + +

Exemplary

Technical Assessment

Poor

• •

Below average

• • •

Average

• • • •

Above average

• • • • •

Excellent

CINEMA Rating Guide

VA

For viewers of all ages

V13

For viewers age 13 and below with parental guidance

V14

For viewers 14 and above

V18

For mature viewers 18 and above

NP

Not for public viewing

 

Title:

GUESS WHO

Running Time: 

105 mins

Lead Cast (voices): 

Bernie Mac, Ashton Kutcher, Zoe Zaldana, Judith Scott, Kallee Stewart

Director: 

Kevin Rodney Sullivan

Producers:

Jason Goldberg, Steve Greener, Ashton Kutcher, Bernie Mac, Erwin Stoff, Betty Thomas, Jenno Topping

Screenwriter: 

David Ronn, Jay Scherick, Peter Tolan

Music:

John Murphy

Editor: 

Paul Seydor

Genre:

Romance/Comedy

Cinematography: 

Karl Walter Lindenlaub

Distributor:

Columbia Pictures

Location: 

USA

Technical Assessment: 

• • •

Moral Assessment: 

+ + +

CINEMA Rating:  

For mature viewers 18 and above

 

In this black-girl-white-boy romance/comedy Theresa (Zoe Saldana) and Simon (Ashton Kutcher) are set to hie off to the suburbs for her parents' 25th wedding anniversary party over the weekend.  They have also decided to announce their engagement there.  Theresa is an artist who has been brought up "to see people, not colors"—thus she doesn't make an issue of informing her parents that her fiance is white.  But Simon—a promising World Street trader who has just quit his job—thinks she should have, lest the folks be shocked.  As it turns out, her upscale parents Percy (Bernie Mac) and Marilyn (Judith Scott) get the surprise of their life.  Understanding the daughter she had brought up, Judith takes it all in stride, but not Percy who runs a credit check on Simon to find out his net worth, and in the process, discovers what Theresa doesn't know: that Simon is unemployed.

Very good chemistry between Saldana and Kutcher makes for a believable truly-in-love couple in Guess Who, but as a comedy, the movie doesn't have enough punch or wit to elicit belly laughs.  There are a few funny-enough lines, and a number of scenes intended to be comic but only turn out to be uncomfortable situations that fail short of their mark—like fireworks that merely sizzle when they're expected to explode.  The character of Mac as the eagle-eyed father of Theresa is so domineering that it eats up everybody sharing the screen with him. Scott and Saladana, however, must be credited for bringing out the best in Mac.  The story is pretty fast-paced; the cinematography, sounds, music and the rest of the cast are okay as far as the story demands.

The stand-out values in the movie are honesty, trust and good communication in relationships, as portrayed by couples Theresa-Simon and Bernie-Marilyn.  As the story unfolds these values are emphasized to be of primary importance if relationships must be fulfilling and lasting. Parental concern for their children's virtue, albeit not entirely selfless in intent (demonstrated by Percy who's so protective of Theresa he sleeps practically chained to Simon in the basement). While the movie is wholesome enough in the American context, caution must be used in allowing young adolescents to see it, lest they think it's smart to (as Theresa does) call your parents by their first names and to talk them down when they're trying to make a point as parents.

 

(Date Reviewed: 22 April 2005)

 

HOMEABOUT USNEWSPROGRAMSDOCUMENTSMOVIE REVIEWSARCHIVES
RATINGSCALENDARPHOTO GALLERYCONTACT USPRIVACY POLICY | LINKS