Moral Assessment

moralrating 

Abhorrent

moralratingmoralrating 

Disturbing

moralratingmoralratingmoralrating 

Acceptable

moralratingmoralratingmoralratingmoralrating 

Wholesome

moralratingmoralratingmoralratingmoralratingmoralrating 

Exemplary

Technical Assessment

techrating 

Poor

techratingtechrating 

Below average

techratingtechratingtechrating 

Average

techratingtechratingtechratingtechrating 

Above average

techratingtechratingtechratingtechratingtechrating 

Excellent

CINEMA Rating Guide

VA

For viewers of all ages

V13

For viewers age 13 and below with parental guidance

V14

For viewers 14 and above

V18

For mature viewers 18 and above

NP

Not for public viewing

 

freedomland

Title:

FREEDOMLAND

Running Time: 

112 mins

Lead Cast:

Samuel Jackson, Julianne Moore, Edie Falco, Ron Eldard

Director: 

Joe Roth

Producer: 

Scott Rubin

Screenwriter: 

Richard Price

Music:

James Newton Howard

Editor: 

Nick Moore

Genre:

Drama/Mystery/Thriller

Cinematography: 

Anastas Michos

Distributor:

 

Location: 

USA

Technical Assessment: 

techratingtechratingtechrating_half 

Moral Assessment: 

moralratingmoralratingmoralrating_half 

CINEMA Rating:  

For mature viewers 18 and above

 

Detective Lorenzo Council (Samuel Jackson) a battle-scarred, long-time policeman is assigned to handle the case of Brenda Martin, (Julianne Moore) who walks into a hospital dazed, confused and bloodied. She reports that she has been car-jacked by a blackman when she made a wrong turn into a seedy part of a predominantly black neighborhood. Upon interrogation, Council finds out that Brenda's four-year-old son, Cody was asleep in the back of the car and was also, purportedly, abducted by the car-jacker. The full might of the New Jersey Police Force, led by Officer Martin (Ron Eldard) Brenda's brother descends on the low-income black community in search of the missing boy. Racial tensions rise as the blacks are angered over the evident display of racial discrimination. Council has to do a balancing act as he tries to defuse the explosive situation and find the missing boy at the same time. The story ends with a shocking revelation on Freedomland, an old, abandoned, dilapidated orphanage with a history of horror and abuse.

Freedomland is trying to do a CRASH, an Academy Award Winner for Best Picture last year. But while Crash is a subtle and complex study of how racial prejudice affects us in almost unconscious ways, this film is a convoluted, melodramatic, badly written and overly directed piece of work. It has as much subtlety as a bull in a China Shop. Nothing in the story and the scenes ring true. The prodigious talents of its lead stars, Jackson and Moore, not to mention Falco are wasted. Instead of soaring and setting us free with its insights of the racial issue, Freedomland has crashed and bogged us down with its heavy-handed treatment stereotypes and complicated story.

Freedomland wears and displays its good intentions but in a heavy-handed way. Take Jackson and Moore for instance: Council (Jackson)Jackson is urbane, cool and skeptic but when he discovers that Cody is inadvertently abducted he gets crazy, goes frenzy and almost collapses into an asthma attack; and Moore, the complete actress that she is, allowing herself to be de-glamorized by playing the role of a flawed and neurotic woman, overplays her part with too much hysterics. Perhaps, the blame could be placed on the long-winding story and the over direction of Joe Roth. What is a simple case of car- jacking turns into a twisted and perplexing story that is too difficult for viewers to unravel.

 

(Date Reviewed: 18 August 2006)

HOMEABOUT USNEWSPROGRAMSDOCUMENTSMOVIE REVIEWSARCHIVES
RATINGSCALENDARPHOTO GALLERYCONTACT USPRIVACY POLICY | LINKS